4.16 — “Bar Association”

4.16 — “Bar Association”

Plot: A dispute between brothers inspires Rom to organize the workers at Quark’s Bar into a union, to the extreme dismay of Quark and the Ferengi Commerce Authority. Meanwhile, Worf moves his quarters onto the Defiant to escape the chaos of DS9.

Thoughts: This episode has the veneer of comic diversion, but it is of deepest significance for Rom, Quark, and Worf. Comedy is serious business! It is strange to reflect that, thanks to teleplay writers Robert Hewitt Wolfe and Ira Steven Behr, the Ferengi episodes are now among my favorites. That’s just about as weird as when the Lwaxana Troi episodes became favorites on TNG.

It’s brave to show what a character looks like under his mask, when he isn’t putting on a public show for others. Armin Shimerman has never been better, revealing Quark as cruel and peremptory, but finding the limits of his conscience. Fine acting abounds everywhere on this episode; which exceeds the standard set on TNG where only a few characters were exceptional.

Is the episode more about Nog, or Quark? We have rarely seen character development done this well on any Star Trek series, not even TOS, which was a different type of show.

I enjoyed the many callbacks to TNG, overt and subtle. Appropriately, the episode was directed by LeVar Burton.

And labor organizing is a topic well worthy of Star Trek! I guess it didn’t fit into TOS or TNG, where this kind of unrest would be out of place–no one was ever exploited. I’m so happy I’m watching this series.

4.5 out of 5 industrial actions.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Bar_Association_(episode)


by

Tags:

Comments

One response to “4.16 — “Bar Association””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes, this was such a great episode! Remember the first Ferengi episode on TNG? The rehabilitation is astonishing.

    There need to be more shows about unions. Some of the lines, like “Ferengi don’t want to stop the exploitation; they want to find a way to become the exploiters.” have that morality play quality that distinguished the original trek and made it special.

    Also, how great is it that the investigator turned on Quark? In a capitalist society, decency and loyalty may easily become subordinate to self interest… also a troubling dynamic one can see in today’s world.

    I especially enjoyed the ending. It is so interesting Armin Shimmerman’s acting choice about how to deliver quark’s last line… he is still not over this defection.

    This episode treats all characters with respect and remains true to their essential natures while telling a redemptive story. It is my favorite episode in a while and my favorite Ferengi episode. It also seems very timely and not dated at all. I would love to see current shows tackling some of these themes.

Leave a Reply to Randi Cohen Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *