3.24 — “Shakaar”

3.24 — “Shakaar”

Plot: A death on Bajor leads to the temporary appointment of Kai Winn as head of the provisional government, ahead of the upcoming elections, in which she is running unopposed. A dismayed Kira is further surprised to be tasked by Winn with negotiating for the return of soil reclamators from the old leader of her resistance cell, Shakaar.

Thoughts: This is a nice episode, featuring some of DS9’s best characters. But it is far from the best episode featuring these characters.

Does Shakaar, played by Duncan Regehr, look familiar? Regehr played Ronin in TNG 7.14, “Sub Rosa.” Yes, the ghost who seduces Beverly Crusher. Now he is being set up as the love interest of another auburn-haired principal cast member.

Why doesn’t this episode excite me more? I think because it reestablishes a previous status quo. A lover of Kira Nerys is installed as the head of the government of Bajor, neatly replacing Vedek Bareil, who was written off the series in episode 3.13, “Life Support.” Kai Winn threatens to increase her power, but ends up in the same station in which she started the episode, with reinforced, but not really new, animosity towards Kira. The illusion of upheaval leaves us back where we were before the death of Bareil. The darts subplot is so slight to be not worth mentioning.

Did anyone enjoy it more than me?

The quote from Odo, “One of the prices of giving people freedom of choice is that sometimes they make the wrong choice” seems like it could have been inspired by current events.

3 out of 5 soil reclamators.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Shakaar_(episode)


by

Tags:

Comments

3 responses to “3.24 — “Shakaar””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    I really liked it. Especially that line of Odo’s. I think it shows the great harm that paranoia, mistrust, and lies can create within a society and the power of love and mutual respect to overcome them. I didn’t feel like it was preordained that Shakaar would live, let alone become so powerful.

    It felt like a nice hopeful ending about people choosing love and to acknowledge each other’s humanity rather than succumbing to paranoia and the illusory safety of staring at someone down the barrel of a firearm.

    I feel like we need more TV like this, these days.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Also it was great to see Kira’s past come more to life through meeting her battle comrades.

  3. Kevin Black Avatar

    You’re rght–I think it’s promising to have a rebel resistance outsider step into the head of the provisional government, who is not part of the religious framework. That gives room for more different perspectives–religious versus military versus farmers/former resistance and such.

    The standoff with the military was a really interesting scene. Everyone knew what their roles were–to kill each other–but they didn’t want to play them and discovered that they didn’t have to. I guess I just wish it were staged more dramatically?

Leave a Reply to Kevin Black Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *