Thine Own Self (episode)

7.16 — “Thine Own Self”

Plot: Data experiences a mishap while recovering radioactive fragments from a downed probe on Barkon IV and loses his memory, wandering into a pre-industrial village. Meanwhile, Troi decides to stand for the Bridge Officer’s Test to become a full commander.

Thoughts: This is a pretty good script by Ronald D. Moore, by recent standards. I love the over-certain native doctor, who confidently pronounces Data an Ice Man and lectures about the elements of rock and fire hidden within wood. If she can’t tell that Data isn’t human, she’s not a very good doctor (not needing to breathe or eat is a tell), but at least the script is witty.

It feels like “Thine Own Self” has the first really independent B story we’ve seen in a while. Elements and structure of the episode feel like old school TNG, but a good version of it. There are a lot of guilty pleasures, like Data getting a spear driven through his chest.

I always wonder, wouldn’t all those blinky lights inside his head show through the skin? Especially skin that’s superficially indistinguishable from human skin, except for color? What function do the lights serve anyway? At least it’s an iconic look.

This tidbit from Memory Alpha is worth quoting: “The story pitch for this episode came from Christopher Hatton…. Hatton pitched his story as ‘Data as Frankenstein’, a concept that Jeri Taylor described as ‘irresistible’. Teleplay writer Ronald D. Moore joked, ‘He wanders into the medieval village, is befriended by the little girl, and villagers come out and chase him with torches!’”

Not only is Data playing the role of Frankenstein’s monster, he also manages to reinvent a few centuries’ worth of scientific advancement in a span of days. I’m going to charitably assume he had the aid of recovered memories to assist him.

This is the 10th TNG episode from the end of the series. Memory Alpha is starting to observe milestones. To wit, this is the last time Riker is seen playing the trombone! Also it is the last appearance of Troi wearing her maroon jumpsuit. Let’s try to hold it together, people.

What did you think? 3.5 of 5 improvised science labs.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Thine_Own_Self


by

Tags:

Comments

6 responses to “Thine Own Self (episode)”

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    I like that the local scientist was ultimately not defensive. And I enjoyed Data’s relationship with the girl. Overall I had fun watching this one, way more than usual. Because science saves the day and the good guys win and tolerance beats intolerance. Not just a technobabble-fest as many recent episodes. This is probably my favorite episode this season.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    PS – Any insight on why the title? It’s better than most for TNG.

  3. Kevin Black Avatar

    It’s from Hamlet, which is traditional for Star Trek, although we haven’t seen it much in TNG. This is probably because the episode was written by Ronald D. Moore, an old-school Trek fan.

    POLONIUS: This above all- to thine own self be true,

    And it must follow, as the night the day,

    Thou canst not then be false to any man.

  4. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes, but not sure how it fits with the plot of the episode exactly. If anything, it seems to be about characters being pushed past their limits to act in new ways.

    In re-reading my review, I realize that not everyone would see the episode as that hopeful. I guess I just felt that Data’s ability to make friends with anyone in this culture is a pretty hopeful sign even if he does get skewered… maybe that is setting the bar pretty low though. 🙂

  5. Kevin Black Avatar

    To the extent that the title is apt (there was a working title, “Jayden”) I would say it’s because Data is searching for himself and his true nature comes through in his desire to help the villagers through scientific inquiry. It’s not the kind of amnesia episode where the character goes ahead and builds a new life that’s completely different from the one they remember and return to at the end of the hour. It is nice to have a title that’s at least three words and has some poetic resonance! When I look at the title in the future, I might remember what episode it refers to.

Leave a Reply to Randi Cohen Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *