5.20 — “Cost of Living”

5.20 — “Cost of Living”

Plot: Lwaxana Troi returns to the Enterprise to prepare for an arranged marriage to a man she’s only met online. She meets and befriends Worf’s son Alexander, in a way that manages to undermine her daughter’s authority as his counselor. Meanwhile, sparkles and goo threaten to eat the ship.

Thoughts: This episode was filmed in early 1992, not long after Gene Roddenberry’s death. This explains the overwrought close up and maudlin delivery of Lwaxana (Majel Barrett-Roddenberry)’s speech about how hard it is to be alone. She still manages to be charming in an episode that is not about very much expect passing some time with the characters and setting up Michael Dorn for moments of brilliant sly comedy.

I’m glad I don’t live on the planet with the dangly earlobes. It looks like they could get caught in stuff, or develop lobe cancer.

One recurring use of the Lwaxana is the trope of “funny nudity”–a cheap special effect to titilate audiences in an era before softcore cable dramas. Is it funny? Seems a little juvenile.

The story between Lwaxana and Alexander is sweet. While the writers still use Lwaxana as a set up for sex jokes, at least she is now established as a wise person, and not the trivial figure from the earliest seasons. So, while this episode is no “Half a Life,” at least it’s not “Ménage à Troi” (no one sexually assaults her for comedic yuks). 

2.5 of 5 earlobes you might need to tie back before eating soup.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Cost_of_Living


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “5.20 — “Cost of Living””

  1. Kevin Black Avatar

    Posted just before midnight EST! I’ll be back on a regular schedule soon.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes.  Totally agree with everything.

    I kind of have this wish that the silly planet was funnier.  

    Majel is lovely, isn’t she?  And this is the first time I’ve actually liked Alexander.  

    Deanna is actually being a teeny bit more sensible than usual in her advice, although I do think that her insistence that child and parent be on an equal plane is a bit odd.

  3. Kevin Black Avatar

    I thought the acting was pretty good. Marina Sirtis raises her game with Majel–probably because she’s being given something real to play. Relationship wise, it is real–Lwaxana undercuts Deanna and refuses to listen in a way that reads as some writers’ lived experience. They are both right from their points of view, but what they can’t do is talk frankly about their disagreements about the approach to Alexander, so they are terrible to each other instead. And so many opportunities to set up Michael Dorn! The slow burn king.

    I’m mostly underwhelmed because I don’t come to Star Trek for relationship drama, and the science fiction elements of this episode, such as they are, are underbaked. It would have been great to get more about the other culture! Then it would have been more like “Half a Life.”

  4. Kevin Black Avatar

    The Internet dating aspect of it is pretty cool, though–before I-dating was a thing. Star Trek nails another future technology prediction.

  5. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Hahaha yes! I thought that too and forgot to say it.

    And totally agree regarding deanna and lwaxana also. They just need to open up and see each others’ perspective. Neither one is acknowledging the fact that it is actually worf’s job to teach Alexander to follow rules though. And that sometimes he can be expected to know better than his child does what behavior is needed. Luckily Alexander is actually a pretty good kid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *