3.11 — “The Hunted”

3.11 — “The Hunted”

Plot: The Enterprise is completing a visit to Angosia III, whose residents seem prime candidates for joining the Federation. On departure, the Prime Minister informs Picard that a prisoner has escaped from their penal colony on Lunar Five and asks for assistance in capturing him. The escapee, Roga Danar, turns out to be a highly clever, engineered supersoldier who helped Angosia win its recent interplanetary war. Deeply affected by their wartime experiences, Roga and his comrades were not welcomed home, but were exiled into permanent isolation. Roga’s skills and volatile temperament now make him highly dangerous.

Thoughts: Star Trek returns to its roots this week, by which I mean it confronts the issue of the war in Vietnam, as it did so often in TOS, in episodes like “Friday’s Child” and “A Private Little War.” This time the metaphorical focus is on the plight of soldiers returning from combat with psychological distress and PTSD. Heavy subject.

On top of this, we have a well-executed action show. Yes, Roga feels a bit overpowered–I really don’t know how he breaks out of the transporter beam (note to self, the transporter is terrifying)–but I was engrossed.

This is the first appearance of the brig in TNG. I’m happy to see them adopt a design which hearkens all the way back to TOS 1.3,  “Where No Man Has Gone Before,” (and to a lesser extent “The Cage”). The presence of the brig does raise the question of how criminal justice is handled aboard the Enterprise, although I know they’re supposed to be over all those difficulties.

The final confrontation, in which Picard sternly tells the Angosians to work out their troubles by themselves, is something I think the episode earns. What an earnest show this is, coming forth during the second half of the Reagan administration (this particular episode aired 1/08/90, during George H.W. Bush’s presidency and eight months before the invasion of Kuwait). The idealism, it almost hurts. 

James Cromwell, who plays Prime Minister Nayrok, would of course go on to become a famous movie actor, and played three more characters in Star Trek, including Zefram Cochrane in Star Trek: First Contact (1996).

Torie and Eugene at TheViewscreen disliked this one (http://www.theviewscreen.com/the-hunted/). I liked it a whole bunch. Watching these episodes is almost disorienting. I’ve been familiar with TNG for 28 years, but my direct experience with the show was based almost entirely on Season One and the feature films. This TNG is like a show I’ve never seen before, and that is exciting. The emphasis seems more on action adventure instead of highbrow concepts like TOS, but that’s okay. The show now has my full attention. Coming to think of it, the return of wounded warriors is a rich and ambitious concept to explore, if a bit simplistically.

4 out of 5 phasers set on overload.

http://en.memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Hunted_(episode)


by

Tags:

Comments

10 responses to “3.11 — “The Hunted””

  1. Kevin Black Avatar

    True, the reference to the Prime Directive at the end is a cop out, since the PD obviously doesn’t apply to interactions with a civilization which is a candidate to join the Federation (or else it could not be such a candidate).

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    I don’t understand why nobody seems to be actually stunned by phasers anymore.

    Decent moral point about veterans (and interesting parallel to PTSD, which also can make people violent). Not really that satisfying a conclusion, and Picard seems not to care about the situation he is leaving behind. Coming right after “The Defector”, which contained genuine emotion, this one just seems to skim the surface of what is possible.

    Also, since they can’t be cured (I guess?) and they feel awful about killing people, I am not sure what is actually a better outcome for these soldiers than what they have, or what they would really want instead. Maybe just a say in what happens to them, even if they reach the same conclusion? Maybe banning future scientific experimentation on others? (This calls to mind that, surprisingly, the Tuskegee experiment was still going on into the 1970’s, and the rules about what is permissible or not as far as human experimentation were only extended to more or less their current form in the 1980’s. So this stuff was slightly more topical then than now… )

  3. Kevin Black Avatar

    Nobody is stunned by phasers, and nothing is picked up by sensor scans. It seems the writers are chafing against conventions of the series that make life a little too easy for the heroes and jeopardy/tension too hard to contrive. This sort of makes sense, since they are going after more of an action/suspense groove and less of a talky one. Irritating to see conventions brushed aside, however.

    I thought the analogy to psychology was pretty clear when they discussed the course of treatment for the soldiers. They were not going to be able to erase what happened to them, but over a course of time, there was hope that they would learn to compensate and reintegrate.

  4. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Maybe I missed the part where they talked about what treatment options were. Except that allowing people to stay untreated for ptsd does not improve their future effectiveness as soldiers so I just don’t get the decision to withhold care. I guess I found the whole genetically engineered killing machine thing to be really distracting to the point where I missed anything else… And it was not explained or explored well.

    Also if psychological intervention were that effective why does troi seem so at a loss? What is her job again?

  5. Kevin Black Avatar

    The dialogue makes it clear that there is a mixture of genetic manipulation and psychological conditioning involved. Then there is this exchange at the end:

    NAYROK: They have been seen moving toward the center of the city. People are scared. Don’t you understand, Captain? They’re dangerous.

    PICARD: You are dangerous. They’re only victims. You made them what they are. You asked them to defend your way of life and then you discarded them.

    ZAYNAR: They were not happy here.

    TROI: They were not welcome here.

    ZAYNAR: It was the will of the people to resettle them.

    NAYROK: No one was pleased with the solution, but we had to act for the greater good.

    DATA: Prime Minister, if you have the skills to create a master soldier, can you not contradict the effect?

    NAYROK: The chemicals can be removed from their systems, but we’re not convinced that the psychological conditioning can ever be entirely reversed.

    DATA: Have you tried, sir?

    NAYROK: We studied it thoroughly. Even before the training began, we knew there would be problems reversing it. It was a risk we had to take.

    WORF: Did you reveal that risk to the men who volunteered for service?

    NAYROK: We were helping them to survive the war, you understand? They needed these skills.

    PICARD: They’re your brothers, your sons, and you turned your backs on them.

    TROI: There are methods of treatment. Until you try them, how can you know they won’t work? Even a partial recovery could give them some peace.

    ZAYNAR: It was the will of the people.

    TROI: To allow them to suffer?

    NAYROK: There was a referendum. The people weighed the costs involved. They chose the resettlement solution.

    ZAYNAR: Besides, we may need to use them again some day.

  6. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yeah. I do remember that dialogue. I guess to me the psychological conditioning or whatever fell more into the category of human experimentation than ptsd since ptsd is neither helpful to warfare nor is it something that is done to people on purpose. This process sounds more like hypnosis or brainwashing. Also Troi should demonstrate a bit more thorough knowledge of the methods than that. I mean, would a science officer get by with “methods are available to determine the atmosphere of this planet”? Would an engineering officer get by with “methods are available to fix your warp core”? A medical officer? It is just lame.

  7. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    Picard and Riker are assessing a candidate planet for entry into the Federation.  While there, a prisoner promptly escapes from their maximum security penal colony, and then eludes the Enterprise (commanded by Data) by using an asteroid as cover.  (But if you can find him, maybe you can hire… the Danar Team!)

    Riker looks uncomfortable around the egghead… and then admits to it!  Oh, Riker, you macho, macho man you.

    It’s nice to see O’Brien call for help before entering the fray.  But why weren’t they using maximum stun in the first place?!?  They were warned this guy was dangerous!  And his looks are slightly reminiscent of the outrageous Okona… ew.

    I can’t help but wonder what horrors the eggheads perpetrated on this guy to make him so dangerously violent.  This has a Weapon X feel to it.  Maybe they should talk to the dude before turning him over to the eggheads.  And Lwaxana is just the person to do it!

    Lwaxana doesn’t simply get ignored by Picard.  When she says the Hunted doesn’t have the personality of a criminal, he listens and helps her to unravel the mystery.  We get to the same point in the story in either case, but I’d like to see a little more professional courtesy extended to Deanna.

    He is Weapon X!  Danar is the Vietnam vet with PTSD.  Nicely done, STNG.

    I don’t understand why Picard has no recourse but to hand over Danar — he can’t offer asylum, or use his report to the Federation as a bargaining chip?  It’s a weak point, as is Danar’s increbile understanding of the layout and computer systems of a Federation starship, as is the idea that all the Enterprise’s sensors could be brought down with a single explosion, as is the anti-intellectual note (can’t trust the eggheads to be in charge!  cue the Danar Team storming egghead HQ!  I love it when a plan comes together).  However, the episode is otherwise very strong, if preachy at the end.

  8. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Oh my gosh… if they got Dwight Schultz (Murdock) to play Danar, that would be so freaking awesome.  

  9. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    Well… I’m extremely happy with Schultz’s character when he does eventually turn up.   Then again, it wouldn’t be the first time an actor played two different roles in the Trek universe.

  10. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Ha, good point!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *