Star Trek Phase II: 4×08 — “Kitumba”

Star Trek Phase II: 4×08 — “Kitumba”

Plot: The Organian Peace Treaty has been shattered, and the Federation intercepts Klingon plans for a massive military assault. Kirk is assigned a desperate peace mission to the Klingon home world, with a traitorous Klingon to guide the ship through its planetary defenses. Yo-yo-ing reversals, incursions, and retreats await in this adventure deep behind enemy lines.

Thoughts: Where have you been? This episode has a pretty great script, very good action, and plays right into the strengths of this fan series by harnessing the amazing energy of fandom with countless extras, a multitude of great sets, and a showcase of impressive special effects involving gigantic enemy space armadas never seen before by me.

I’m not sure I followed every beat of the story, or that every beat was defensible. I don’t know what point they were making with all the disintegrations at the end of the story, for example. I don’t like the direction they have taken with McCoy, and and some of the actors are a bit grating. But still, this was a pretty great episode.

Some things I noticed: it was a nice touch in the beginning to recreate the same space station model that was used in “The Trouble With Tribbles.” This is the first time in the fan film series that we see Klingons with forehead ridges, and the script includes a nod to the retconned explanation for this discrepancy provided in Star Trek: Enterprise.  I caught other references to Enterprise. The reference to “President Archer,” would no doubt make more sense if I had ever watched the show. Hey, at the rate this community is going, we may get to start it in, uh, six or seven years? Ulp.

Rating: Definitely well worth the trouble.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=419hNYe2OaY


by

Tags:

Comments

2 responses to “Star Trek Phase II: 4×08 — “Kitumba””

  1. Kevin Black Avatar

    Note–this is the last full length episode available, but we will end our trip through Phase II on Friday with the anticlimatic vignette, “Going Boldly” (starring the new actor tapped to play Kirk).

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Hmm.  So, cool that Buck Rogers (Gil Gerard) made a cameo appearance as that Star Fleet official at the beginning.  Still has that same devilish grin!

    Not sure if I followed the whole plot either.  In particular, not sure why they couldn’t just kill the bad guy when he sent the guards away, rather than let him stab Spock… odd.

    Also, why did Kitumba need to use Kirk if he knew that guy was bad news all along?  Surely there are less complicated ways to have his regent killed.

    Overall it was still fun though, I particularly liked the bar scene and that Uhura gets a few cute lines that make her sound halfway knowledgeable.

    Nice to see Kargh again, a few too many eyebrow raised but overall he is a very convincing Klingon.  Hilarious how much shorter he is than the Kitumba or K’Sha.

    Ugh, I find it odd that the medical officer is commenting constantly on tactical/leadership matters, it doesn’t seem to me that that is his role.

    And, hey, the guy that plays the new Kirk seems slightly less annoying!  We will see…

    Overall, I paid more attention to this episode than prior ones, it seemed like there was more happening.  Glad we are getting back to the “real episodes” soon though!  

    So, now that we are done with the fan series, what’s next??  Speed up the animated series?  Start a new one?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *