Star Trek Phase 2: 4×07 — “The Child”

Star Trek Phase 2: 4×07 — “The Child”

Plot: A being of pure energy enters the Enterprise while the ship is passing through an energy cloud and implants a child in the womb of a Deltan Ensign. While the child quickens and grows in mysterious ways, the ship is pursued by a strange vessel of unknown intention and origin.

Thoughts: This production is still in desperate need of a lighting designer. I’m convinced that inept lighting is responsible for much of the pain involved in watching this episode. Certainly not all.

Grump, grump, grump. The new actor playing Spock doesn’t even register on screen as more important than any other background character. The rest of the actors are not growing on me–especially not the one who plays Peter Kirk. The episode just isn’t up to the production quality standards set by the early episodes, and the limp plot doesn’t make up for any of these deficiencies. The premise is completely outrageous, yet I feel like the cast is tiptoeing around the whole time pretending that it isn’t a story about immaculate conception, rape, and victim pathology. Hence, the episode skips along the line that separates lame from offensive, sometimes landing lightly on one side, sometimes the other. Unlike earlier episodes, there are no really impressive special effects to speak of. The result is perilously close to being tedious, which may be the worst sin of all.

Rating: skippable.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFyKrrF-obY


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “Star Trek Phase 2: 4×07 — “The Child””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    oh I don’t know, I think there were some interesting ideas in there about the deltans and i would love to know more about their oath of celibacy and why that exists. and the suspense factor was not bad although admittedly I watch these while doing other things.

    dislikes were: xon makes spock less cool, child actor was pretty unengaging, it would not have been that hard to address the unwilling conception issue and the fact that it was blown right past is disturbing as you point out, kev.

    overall I am glad I watched it for completeness and found it a more pleasant experience than some others, ie the bloodworm episode.

  2. Kevin Black Avatar

    It bothered me that the character went from conception to delivery in 3 days, the child then aged (despite consuming normal amounts of food) something like a year per day, until it conveniently reached the age of the child actor they’d hired and then stopped aging. I think it was Kirk running around saying “I can’t believe you all aren’t freaking out more about this”–uh, yeah, understatement.

  3. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Well, yeah, that was obviously done for convenience’s sake.  Imagine how many children you could have if they all aged that way!  Holy population explosion!  It is interesting that Kirk’s role in this is to be the only person who is alarmed by stuff.  Normally that would be McCoy’s job.  I’d like to be a Vulcan by the way… no headaches!

  4. Liam Vicarious Avatar

    Just a quick question. Are these guys going to do a rehashing of all the old storylines from TOS ans TNG…this one is obviously like the “Child” episode in TNG..I’m not ripping on any of these so far I’m just curious as to if any of the writers have an actual Original idea 😉 😉 ya dig…I like the idea of new missions but two out of them so far are just…eh lets take this old one and put a spin on it..

    All in all I love that they brought back original cast members and I’m glad that these people care enough to bring this awesome show back to us in some form…so I will keep watching 🙂 Lol

  5. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Hmmm, not sure if I saw that episode!  I guess when we get to TNG I will get to see if they do the concept any more justice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *