3.4 — “And the Children Shall Lead”

3.4 — “And the Children Shall Lead”

Plot: What does the Enterprise find, responding to a distress call on the planet Triacus? Dead bodies strewn everywhere, apparently from a mass suicide. The children of the research party survive, apparently unconcerned and unaffected by their parents’ deaths. Creepy, huh? Determined to get to the bottom of this, Krik takes the children on board the Enterprise, where they soon start to take over the ship.

Thoughts: This is a very dark episode. For the line “We’ll have to kill them.” For scenes of mass suicide, and rejoicing at expressions of childhood trauma. For the accidental beaming of a pair of security guards into deep space–in a scene in which the audience knows what is happening, but Kirk is two steps behind. To make a long story short–I like this episode much better than I expected!

Starting back from the beginning–is it always automatically going to be just Kirk, Spock, and McCoy beaming down in all the landing parties now? Don’t tell me they dug all those graves by themselves. Nice UFP pennant–but it doesn’t seem very sturdy.

It’s great, at long last, to be seeing new areas of the Enterprise again. Behold, the cafeteria and the arboretum!

The writers/producers must have thought kids were quite resilient back in the 1960s. McCoy’s thesis seems to be that as long as they can cry, they’ll be okay. Since each of these kids is a patricide as well as an orphan, I’m not so sure. How developed are social services in space, anyway? Is there interstellar foster care? An outer space adoption agency?

The redhead kid (Craig Hundley) has bad luck. Besides playing Tommy in this episode, he also played Kirk’s newly orphaned nephew in 1.29 –“Operation: Annihilate!” (in which episode, he also filmed a scene on the bridge). Craig’s wikipedia page (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Craig_Hundley) is totally fascinating. Check it out–I don’t want to spoil it.

Perhaps they could have cast a better actor to play the Angel/Gorgan, but I’ll give him points for being creepy. He’s the spirit of evil, and comes off as a pedophile. I like the idea of having to conquer the fear within you to prevail. This episode is at least moderately well thought out. I don’t mind an episode being a little bit slow-moving when there is genuine suspense and I can’t tell how the episode will end. I don’t recall ever seeing this one before–it’s the kind of show you would expect to remember.

The scene with Kirk and Spock in the turbolift is quite slasherific! I also enjoyed watching Chekov try to arrest Kirk and Spock.

Chekov training a phaser on the captain, while under the control of an alien intelligence… does this remind anyone else of Star Trek II?

3 out of 5 nasty bowls of vanilla coconut synthesized ice cream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_the_Children_Shall_Lead


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “3.4 — “And the Children Shall Lead””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Wow.  Have not seen the ep yet, hope to start catching up tomorrow, but boy is that quite a wikipedia page!  Thanks for pointing that out, Kev.  Looks like acting in several major TV series was just a side job for Craig.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes, I quite liked this one, despite certain ridiculous elements (i.e. why not stun the kids once you figure out they are behind this?  and, why is Kirk suddenly immune when nobody else is?  and “look at how horribly ugly he is… and don’t be afraid”… really?  has the person who wrote this ever met a child?).  I enjoyed the Shatnerian scene chewery in the elevator, for once it was somewhat appropriate for the content.

    Speaking of which, this content is so disturbing I actually object to actors that young being made to act about it… not sure why society thinks this is OK.  

    OK, so none of that is particularly praising of this episode.  I did think it had tons of cool ideas.  Not sure if the mass suicide by mind control started here or if it was a common theme before this, but it rather reminds me of “The Happening”, if anyone watched that a few years ago.  And it is a chilling supposition.

    I thought this was better done than “Wolf in the Fold” with a similar type of villain, although certainlly the actor was just awful… not even sure what anyone was going for with that style of delivery.   But “Wolf in the Fold” had less suspense, I think because of the lack of the rather interesting characters of the children.  I did think the redhead kid was really convincing in his role, although honestly the turn-about at the end was considerably less convincing.  If that creature could give the kids powers to distort others’ perceptions, surely it had its own such powers.  Plus that scene of playing around in the settlement looked horribly staged and uncomfortable.  Almost as uncomfortable as Captain Kirk with a crying little girl in his arms!  Apparently William Shatner has 3 daughters… one would never know it from this scene!

    Oh well.  I give it three out of five foam gravestones, for being interesting enough that i am motivated to critique it at this length.  

  3. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    Yes, too many ludicrous elements — we don’t check our instruments to make sure of our position before accidentally beaming crewmen into space?   In the end, I just can’t get past the idea that the children could be convinced to participate in the destruction of their own parents, but then are rather quickly “saved” by Kirk.

    Sarah MacMillan  also points out that the metaphor is not well thought out — calling it “the Beast” implies a kind of gnawing anger/rage that could explode and lead you to do awful things; instead, this appears to be their greatest fears, which would tend to paralyze rather than call to action.

  4. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes… I agree that the presumably complete corruption then quick redemption of the kids was the most unbelievable thing in the episode, or at least the most unforgivable unbelievable thing since it is so central to the plot.

  5. Katharine Bond Avatar

    I also agree that the children don’t behave entirely in the way that you’d expect children to behave.

    But, really, my biggest beef is with what turns out to be Uhura’s fear. Really? She’s most afraid of turning into an old woman. How stereotypical.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *