2.21 — “Patterns of Force”

2.21 — “Patterns of Force”

Plot: The Enterprise enters a system with two inhabited planets. It is looking for history professor John Gill, previously sent there on a cultural mission. Kirk and Spock find the inner planet overrun by soldiers wearing Nazi uniforms. Earth Nazis, how curious! A viewscreen indicates that John Gill is the Führer of the state (planet?). After this, it is logical to steal some Nazi uniforms and try to infiltrate the mysterious Führer’s inner sanctum. It is also logical for Kirk and Spock to lose their shirts, and get whipped by a cat of nine tails. I have a headache.

Thoughts: It takes some brass balls (ovaries?) to do an episode in which your leads all dress up as Nazis. That doesn’t, however, automatically make it a good idea.

The producers do like to play dress up with Leonard Nimoy. That is a good idea.

The episode doesn’t really hold together, and at times becomes borderline offensive. Hahaha, let’s psychoanalyze the Nazis and show how the evil they caused could have easily been avoided.

The story tries to make points about the inherent dangers of power, even accumulated for a benign purpose, while having as much fun as it can raiding Paramount’s costume closet. It’s too simple though. Oh really–totalitarianism might be just fine, if only the leaders aren’t psychopathic jerks?

This is another non-interference directive episode. These are coming fast and furious in Season Two, after “The Apple,” “A Piece of the Action,” and “A Private Little War.” In some ways “Patterns of Force” is very derivative of previous episodes. Gill is just another famous leader gone bad on an away mission, like Kurtz in Heart of Darkness–or Adams and Korby in “Dagger of the MInd” and “What Are Little Girls Made Of?” I will grant that the producers have succeeded, once again, in creating a vibe that is completely different from the preceding 49 episodes (holy cow! this is episode 50!). The episode with all the Nazis does tend to stand out in the memory.

I found two interesting tidbits reading Memory Alpha (http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Patterns_of_Force):

1. This episode marks the only time, in any Star Trek series or film, that actor Leonard Nimoy is seen on camera not wearing a shirt; and 

2. The episode’s thesis that Germany, and especially Nazi Germany, was the “most efficient” state in history, was popular in 1960s America; it is, however, strongly denied by modern historians that point to the many bloated, competing bureaucracies with ill-defined areas of competence that existed in that period, mostly financed with stolen and expropriated funds.

 

A generous 2 of 5 rubindium crystals.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patterns_of_Force_(Star_Trek:_The_Original_Series)


by

Tags:

Comments

10 responses to “2.21 — “Patterns of Force””

  1. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    Agreed; this is not a particularly inspired episode.  Just a couple notes:

    1. Wasn’t Scotty supposed to beam them up after a few hours?  How did Kirk and Spock get into so much trouble so quickly?

    2. It’s ironic that Gill’s “random sentences strung together” sounds like most political speeches of our lifetime.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Hahahahaha, Alex!

    I kind of liked this episode.  The whole premise that anyone would go and create Nazi Germany on purpose with some premise other than gaining absolute power kind of does not make any sense, but I did like the characters and suspense and I do always like the ones with happy endings… although the new rulers sure have a job cut out for them… and why does one of them have a British accent but nobody else does?  Is he supposed to represent Winston Churchill or something?

    3 out of 5 fake shots to the belly.

  3. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    The other thing I found hard to believe was the number of well-placed people in the Reich who were actually members of the resistance.  Kirk needed to call a head count at the end; they might have outnumbered the Nazis in that room!

  4. Kevin Black Avatar

    Is it permitted to say that the uniforms do look snazzy? The Reich at least had a sense of sartorial drama. I also enjoyed Spock explaining to McCoy the logical way to put on a boot.

  5. Kevin Black Avatar

    I also didn’t know until I starting googling information related to this episode that Shatner and Nimoy are both Jewish, to the extent that matters. This is the era of Hogan’s Heroes (1965-1971), so I guess dressing up like Nazis on TV in semi-comic situations was seen as less weird than it seems to me now.

  6. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes… I find myself wondering if perhaps it would have made sense for #3 to off malaki somehow and then just assume command. .. weird that#3 would not know that John Gill is drugged? Not sure how malaki kept that secret for so long?

    I feel like before schindlers list you could do nazi comedy. After that movie, well, it just doesn’t feel right. 

  7. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    IIRC, that was Spielberg’s experience — Nazis were used to comic effect in the Indiana Jones movies, but after Schindler’s List, he said he wouldn’t use them as comic-book villains anymore.

  8. Kevin Black Avatar

    Weren’t there Nazis in Kingdom of the Crystal Skull? Anyways.

  9. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    No.  Those were Soviets. 

  10. Katharine Bond Avatar

    Ugh…the historian in me really hates this episode. Really truly.

    On the other hand, it does fairly accurately reflect mid 60s American historography on the subject of Nazi Germany. So, in that respect, it’s an interesting cultural artifact.

Leave a Reply to Randi Cohen Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *