2.16 — “The Gamesters of Triskelion”

2.16 — “The Gamesters of Triskelion”

Plot: Kirk, Chekhov, and Uhura are snatched from the Enterprise and transported to Triskelion to serve as thralls for the Providers. Three “drill thralls” are assigned to train them–for gladiatorial combat! Back on the ship, Spock, McCoy, and Scotty try to figure out where their missing crewmates have gone.

Thoughts: This episode is most memorable for its design–the combat ring set with the funny triple lightning bolt, and the amazing disco fetish costumes worn by the alien thralls. One thrall is dressed like Dracula, one like the giants from “The Galileo Seven,” and Shahna looks just like Lady Gaga! 

I thought the story, which can be described as Captain-Kirk-as-John-Carter-of-Mars, left a lot to be desired, however. Let’s start at the beginning. Not very nice of Kirk and Chekhov to let Uhura fight 2 against 1! I like that at the end of the teaser, Lady Gaga is going to kill Captain Kirk.

The indoor set is a fairly literal interpretation of all of Kirk’s speeches about how humans can’t be made to live in cages, heard most recently in “Metamorphosis.”

I’m not fond of the way the producers play the masculine voice of the orange female drill thrall for yuks, especially since this is another “humans are awesome!”-themed episode. “It’s the custom of our people to help one another when we’re in trouble.” Unless you look like a chick and sound like a dude.

The attack on Uhura, seen only in shadow while Kirk watches helplessly, was both tough to watch and highly effective.

Brains come in three fruit flavors! Talk about a poor man’s Talosians. Does Kirk have the right to potentially wager away his whole crew’s right to resist perpetual alien enslavement? Even if necessary to prevent their immediate annihilation? He could be bluffing, but if so, why should he depend on the Gamesters to keep their word? I guess he was in a poor bargaining position.

I have to address Kirk’s chutzpah–the way he shamelessly manipulates Shahna into falling for him and takes advantage of her romantic feelings for his personal benefit and the benefit of the crew. We’ve seen behavior like this before, in “The Conscience of the King,” “Catspaw,” “MIrror, Mirror,” and probably others. I guess this shows Kirk’s ingenuity and resolve, but it’s awfully callous. I might have almost forgiven him, even after he gave that terrible break-up speech to Shahna (“You want to come with me, baby? Naaah, there’s so much you must learn here first”), if he hadn’t capped it by coming in for one last kiss before dematerializing. One more little thrill before goodbye forever. Can’t read my p-p-p-poker face, baby. That’s really douchey.

I don’t mind wild episodes, but this one is wild in all the wrong ways for my taste. Also? I don’t like Chekhov. Please come back soon, George, from filming The Green Berets.

2 out of 5 wagers that Kirk is incorrigibly untrainable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gamesters_of_Triskelion


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “2.16 — “The Gamesters of Triskelion””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Hmmm.  Thought I posted a comment here but apparently it never appeared?

    Short version: Kirk = douchey (totally agree!).  Uhura = raped but nobody notices for the rest of the episode, or the series?  Chekhov = playing his scene for a cheap laugh, which ruins not just the scene but the dramatic development of the episode in general.  Scotty & Bones = double douchey and if I were Spock I would have talked to each of them the instant that crap attitude started.  Scotty does a better job for crazy people in charge of the Enterprise than he does for Spock whom he should respect.  What the heck?  Vulcan prejudice?

    Interesting moment when Uhura refuses to beat up the black slave, particularly interesting b/c race issues still very hot when TNG was filmed.

    Shahna is appealing, probably more so than any other character in this episode.  She gives Kirk waayyyy too much credit throughout but has an appealing blend of strength and naivete.  And I think Kirk should have offered to take her back to her home planet at least.  

    Philosophical point that there is more to life than having everything you want is well taken.  And that helping others is more entertaining and challenging overall than hurting them.  Should be obvious, but I guess the skittles guys have Asperger’s so perhaps it truly does not occur to them.

    Overall: 2 out of 5 arenas with thinly disguised Nazi symbols.  (Triskelion = Third Reich?)  Would have been 3 but took 1 point off for douchiness of nearly all characters.

  2. Kevin Black Avatar

    It’s interesting that the scene with the attack on Uhura is really more about Kirk, and his helplessness to come to the aid of his crew while being locked in a cage, than it is about Uhura. And I pretty much went with it on that level, and didn’t think much about aftermath. She has suffered some indignities this season, following the brain wipe in “The Changeling”–although NN probably preferred this to just saying “hailing frequencies are open, sir” ad nauseum. Btw, NN turned 81 yesterday.

  3. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Yes she has! To say the least! At least with the brain wipe there was some semblance of a recovery period. Choice to make this storyline about Kirk instead of the actual victim plays as highly misogynistic to me, even more than usual for the series. Not to mention, kirk said nothing to uhura about it later despite supposedly being tortured by it. Poorly done, sttos, poorly done!

  4. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    “On the contrary, they are extremely fair, since your alternative is death.”  Ha-ha!

    That and Shahna (the green hair reminds me a bit of Zeetha; the outfit reminds Sarahmac of Madonna’s) are the saving graces of this episode.

  5. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    Also, YES, we need George Takei back soon.  Not only to save us from too much Chekov (it feels like he’s received more screen time than Uhura and Sulu combined), but also from shirtless Kirk.

Leave a Reply to R. Alex Reutter Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *