2.10 — “Journey to Babel”

2.10 — “Journey to Babel”

Plot: The Enterprise is assigned to transport a shipload of ambassadors to a Federation council. What could go wrong? Murder. Assault. Ship-to-ship battles. Medical emergencies. Intrigue. Stiff-necked Vulcan pride. This episode features Spock’s Vulcan father, Ambassador Sarek, with whom Spock has been estranged for 18 years, and his human mother, Amanda.

Thoughts: There are a few episodes which, through exercise of imagination, forever expand the universe of Star Trek, and the possibilities that exist for later writers. “Journey to Babel” is such an episode. Spock and Vulcans are changed: through Spock’s relation to Sarek we now have a much clearer picture of Vulcan society than could be gleaned from “Amok Time.” More importantly, Starfleet is changed. It is now a parliamentary body that has councils and intrigues and politics between member races. And the Star Trek universe now contains Andorians, Tellarites, and Orions, along with a verbal callback  to Romulans and Klingons (for what I believe is the first time?), establishing them as recurring characters in the series, not just one-off villains from Season One. After “Babel,” the Star Trek universe is a bigger, roomier, more well-defined place. Could Deep Space Nine could have existed without this episode? The Cantina scene in Star Wars? Babylon 5? This is also an episode that establishes, budget be damned, they’ll fill the screen with alien races if that’s what the story calls for.

First season featured episodes told in many different styles. The tradition continues with this one resembling a soap opera: family drama, medical emergencies, airing of old grudges and recriminations, with dramatic scenes played in the operating room, bed room,  board room, and bridge.

Leonard Nimoy is just great here. I’m not sure how he manages to play Spock as being crushed and impassive at the same moment, but he makes it crystal clear what the character is going through and you always feel exactly where he’s at. The scenes between him and Amanda, especially the scene in Spock’s quarters where she begs him to save his father’s life, are just fabulous television. And she has a great right cross!

The bar scene may call to mind the Cantina, but the Tellarites look most like Ugnaughts. The difference between Star Trek and Star Wars is that in the remastered version of “Journey to Babel,” the Andorian still stabs Kirk first.

You can’t watch this episode and not want to see Spock’s Sehlat with the 6-inch fangs. Star Trek fans got to do that in 1973, in the Animated Series episode “Yesteryear,” scripted again by D.C. Fontana. I had a View-Master reel of that episode at the age of 7 or 8.

I like Dr. McCoy shushing people at the end of the episode like Dr. Evil. And seeing Sarek’s touching relationship with Amanda. He’s as passionate as his son, isn’t he? That’s the secret of Vulcans–they didn’t develop their emotion-negating philosophy for no reason. I like the way Mark Lenard slyly shows Sarek’s wisdom, knowing that through his marriage he has made a choice to walk down human and Vulcan paths simultaneously, as his son is forced to do by his biology.

I don’t know, however, why Sarek didn’t seek medical attention for his heart condition while he was still on Vulcan. It would have been logical.

5 out of 5 blood cells T-negative.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journey_to_Babel


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “2.10 — “Journey to Babel””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Not much to add to what Kevin has so aptly stated.  Great episode.  Why not break off the other antenna?  What do Orions look like anyway?  Why is the beginning of Kirk’s fight with the Andorian cut off?  Just too much material to fit into one episode I guess.  

    Love the eyeless pig people.  They are fun.  As well as the little gold guys drinking the drink with the colored ice cubes.  Just such a rich imagination that went into this episode.  And, what would you do in Spock’s position if Kirk hadn’t rousted himself out of sickbay?  Honestly, do you think Scotty would have been able to prevail in this situation?  I am not sure.  I think 

    Spock’s dilemma is a real one even if you are not a Vulcan.

    5 out of 5 repaired Vulcan heart valves (how many do they have anyway?)

  2. Kevin Black Avatar

    I enjoyed the smash cut to the fight scene in the hallway. It’s a WAKE UP!–what’s going on?? moment.

  3. Bill Testerman Avatar

    Leave it to D. C. Fontana to give us more good background on the Vulcans. I think she became the in-house expert on Vulcans among the ST production crew. I also enjoyed her novel Vulcan’s Glory, which she wrote a few years ago, about Spock serving with Captain Pike.

    That’s a good question, Kevin, why Sarek did not already seek treatment for his heart condition. And why, after Amanda stormed out of Spock’s quarters, did the door not open when Spock walked up to it? (Answer: the guy operating the door had been told not to open it right then.)

    I was fortunate to meet Mark Lenard (Sarek) at another sci-fi convention in Salem, Virginia sometime around 1998. He seemed very friendly and easy-going. As, one afternoon when I was in a line to get his autograph, there was a guy in front of me who was carrying on about nonsense like he was high or had a mental problem. Those of us around him tried to humor him as best we could. When we got to Mr. Lenard’s table, the guy asked Mr. Lenard to repeat these inane lines the guy had written for him. And Mr. Lenard patiently repeated the lines as though he was glad to, which went on for about 5 minutes as he continued to sign autographs. I was impressed. By the way, as far as I know Mark Lenard is still the only actor to portray all 3 major aliens on ST – a Vulcan, a Klingon, and a Romulan.

  4. R. Alex Reutter Avatar

    I find it totally implausible that Kirk doesn’t know about his top subordinate’s family — he would have a dossier on each and every member of the crew, and you can bet he’d know who Spock’s parents were.  It makes a great opening for Kirk to put his foot in it, but might have been even better (and more subtle) if Kirk offers himself as a poor substitute tour guide and gives Spock the bridge.

    The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few!  Great plotting here with Spock’s “dilemma”, which is no logical dilemma to Spock, of course.

    What’s up with Sarek the totally undiplomatic diplomat?  In every episode, these guys are all terrible at their jobs.  Save us, Lwaxana Troi!  The Andorian ambassador is great.

    Dead diplomat with initial guilt falling on the wrong person.  Presages of Trek VI, only I liked this better.

    He’s not Andorian!  Nice twist.

    I find it even more totally implausible that Spck’s mom has so little understanding of Vulcans.  Sorry, her relationship with Sarek does not feel loving; too much condescension from Sarek.   I liked her character much more as written in Star Trek IV — cool and attracted to logic, but still very human, and not ready to emotionally blow up at Spock and Sarek when they act in a perfectly logical fashion — and it’s the same actress.  (The costumers also did better by the actress; she looks much better in Star Trek IV, too!)

  5. Kevin Black Avatar

    Chrissie’s transcripts confirm it’s 18! Review corrected. 🙂 And welcome.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *