5.10 — “New Ground”

5.10 — “New Ground”

Plot: Worf’s son, Alexander, returns to the ship with Worf’s adoptive human mother, who tells Worf that Alexander needs his father’s presence. And besides, we’re tired. Can Worf balance his shipboard duties with childrearing? Also, the discovery of a new form of propulsion excites Geordi.

Thoughts: I wonder why K’Ehleyr named their son Alexander, which fits with Worf’s Russian parents, but not with the circumstances of Alexander’s birth, which was concealed from Worf at the beginning. Was K’Ehleyr a half-human yet raised by Klingons, while Worf was all Klingon, but raised by humans? There’s so little to go on with those two. I start to understand the enticement of fan fiction.

The success of “New Ground” is in telling universal stories–the tradeoff between family and career, conflicts between parents and grandparents, you can come at it from a lot of angles and find something to relate to.

Male privilege is written all over the premise. Alexander accuses Worf, “My mother wouldn’t send me away!” — and he’s right. K’Ehleyr was a goddamned secret agent, the Klingon Wonder Woman, offered an unheard-of spot on the Klingon High Council, but she would never have sent her son away, it would be unthinkable. Yet for Worf, fatherhood is such a paradigm shift and sacrifice. We’re supposed to feel bad for him. Alexander should go back with his grandmother–how dare she refuse him?

And I do feel bad for Worf, kind of. Michael Dorn makes it relatable. But male privilege is blazoned everywhere.

It’s always interesting to see Deanna do her job. Worst counselor ever? Perhaps, but she has the opportunity to do some good here nevertheless. She’s presented with such low-hanging fruit. Still, as television therapists go, she’s no Dr. Melfi.

The structure of the A and B stories are very predictable. So, you take your pleasures where you can find them, in the performances, in an exchange of looks. I’m glad that Riker saved the rubber sock puppet.

2.5 of 5 elementary-level calisthenics.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/New_Ground


by

Tags:

Comments

5 responses to “5.10 — “New Ground””

  1. Allen Knutson Avatar

    K’Ehleyr was one of my favorites. Suzi Plakson is so great at the comic reaction shot. I loaded a Klingon font into my thesis so I could put a lousy pun on “Kähler geometry” into a citation.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Oh my gosh… I am still so mad that she is dead!

    This episode was… OK.  I’m not as pleased as usual with Michael Dorn.  He didn’t do a great job of making the bonding with Alexander believable, also that was clearly a styrofoam prop that he was “straining” to lift.  Yes, nice muppet-saving, Riker!

    That teacher… her eyes just look huge.  It’s distracting.

    I was just laughing at the part when Worf is trying to work and he is continually interrupted by Alexander-related stuff… welcome to my life!!!  It hadn’t even occurred to me to be annoyed about it, but yes, male privilege indeed.

    Deanna was less horrible than usual here, I agree.  But yes, pretty low-hanging fruit.  And it would have been much more interesting to actually see a family therapy session.   

  3. Kevin Black Avatar

    In retrospect, I’m annoyed that they couldn’t manage to tell the story better. I mean, I was annoyed at the time, but it’s persistently irritating. The story is about Worf realizing that his relationship with his son is meaningful to him, and we can’t figure out any way to dramatize that other than putting the kid in physical danger so that Worf has to run inside a burning building (er, museum) to save him. Are we 12?

    I wish it could be written just as a good dramatic story, so it doesn’t matter that they’re on the Enterprise or that they’re Klingons.

  4. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Totally well put!!!  The awkward part initially was, I thought, very well done.  But the resolution was super-lame.  And we never got to hear Alexander’s viewpoint on any of it.  I did like Worf bringing up K’Ehleyr explicitly.  But I would have liked to hear him apologize for his lack of curiosity about his son and try to do better.  Even at the end he is doing all of the talking and none of the listening.  (Except for the interrogation part, which wasn’t actually curiosity about Alexander at all).

  5. Kevin Black Avatar

    Off topic, I have spent the whole day until now believing that it is still Wednesday. I better post the Star Trek!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *