5.7 — “Unification I”

5.7 — “Unification I”

Plot: Ambassador Spock is missing. The search for Spock takes Picard to Romulus, where the ambassador is suspected by Starfleet of defecting. But first Picard must visit Qo’noS and Vulcan, to pay a visit to a close acquaintance from last season….

Thoughts: I can’t explain how special it is to see Leonard Nimoy here in TNG in character as Spock (if only briefly). Having him share the screen with Picard (surely we will get a two shot of them together in Part II?) is just brain bending. Part of this is the realization that this and the next episode are the last “new” performances of Nimoy as Spock that I will ever see.

Nimoy agreed to do this two-part episode, which aired on November 4, 1991, as cross promotion for Star Trek VI, which was a month away from its opening in theaters on December 6th. We also get the memorial card for Gene Roddenberry, who died on October 24th.

I don’t like the pacing of the two-part episodes very much; a lot of the action ends up feeling like filler. They try to make the extra time worthwhile by revisiting some of TNG’s greatest hits with Gowron (who is extensively discussed, but does not appear) and Sarek. It is striking how little chemistry the actor who plays Perrin has with her husband, Sarek. Some of Sarek’s scenes could have been shot differently, like with the characters making eye contact, and not strangely shouting at each other. Marc Lenard’s performance gives Sarek emotional weight, however (if not the discipline of logic).

So, Gowron is now denying the friends who defended him. For a culture which places a high value on honor, Klingons seem to have a strange definition of what it means. I fear there is a syndrome in the writing of Star Trek where any unsavory attribute can be applied to a Klingon and seem to fit. I thought of this again when the Klingon captain seems to be too scared to go into the Neutral Zone, and is dismissive of Picard and Data’s bravery. Sure, this behavioral is unlikable, but it doesn’t seem very Klingon.

The smirking is back in the Riker subplot. Gah! I do like the alien with the calculator epaulets. An attempt is made to do something worthwhile with the Troi character. It misfires.

The effort to disguise Picard and Data as Romulans is, of course, a callback to TOS 3.2, “The Enterprise Incident.” I’ll be very disappointed if there isn’t a direct reference to this in Part II. Dressing up as Romulans is a bit of good fun, but why is Crusher so concerned about being able to return Data’s skin pigment to yellow?

The actual reconnaissance mission is disappointing. Apparently they have no cover prepared, for this infiltration into a planet obsessed with espionage and security. Which means Picard and Data are on a suicide mission, but it’s played for yuks. Yuck.

Still, I’m excited for Part II. Spock!

3 of 5 space junkyards.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Unification_I


by

Tags:

Comments

2 responses to “5.7 — “Unification I””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    I am feeling… Sarek’s pajamas.  Picard’s negotiating chutzpah.  “You may have… the shelf.”  Random shot of awesome Klingon claw-boots just before Picard gets the news of Sarek’s death (both of which seem somewhat irrelevant to the plot).

    Not loving… that rando female Admiral’s uniform-dress in the beginning.  Super uncomfortable-looking and unflattering.  Sarek’s wife (way too naturalistic in her acting style.  Needs more gravitas.)  The entire plot (meandering).  Deanna finding it cute that she is basically being harrassed by an elderly curmudgeon (while wearing a skin-tight outfit)… ugh, so very very gross.  Klingons acting once again like honorless jerks 

    just for the heck of it.

    More later!

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    OK, totally agree that Picard is acting uncharacteristically ridiculous… who beams down to Romulus without even an agreed-upon cover story or practicing the deception????  This is like “A Piece of the Action” without the humor or cleverness.  Plus Kirk and Spock in suits are kind of hotter than Picard and Data in Romu-gear.

    There is something a bit xenophobic about how classless the Klingons seem to act despite being called an “honor based society” and also how illogical/emotional the Vulcans are portrayed as acting despite being called “logical”.  It’s annoying and harks back to first season in which the crew were acting incompetent and yet being called the “best ship in the fleet”, Worf being called a “great warrior” and yet being beaten up by basically everybody (this is mostly still happening although not quite as much lately), Deanna being called a “ship’s counselor”  yet functioning more like a ship’s annoying busybody and hot female.

    Ugh.  Well, anyway, SPOCK.  So it’s kind of worth watching regardless.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *