4.15 — “Sons of Mogh”

4.15 — “Sons of Mogh”

Plot: Worf’s brother Kuhn arrives at DS9, after losing his position on the Klingon High Council and suffering the dissolution of the House of Mogh at the hands of Chancellor Gowron based on Worf’s political opposition. His request is for death at his brother’s hand.

Thoughts: This is a sharp, well-acted episode full on interpersonal conflict. It literally starts with Worf fighting Dax, then stabbing Kuhn, and that’s just the end of the first act. There was a lot more of main characters yelling at each other than I’m used to.

All this opposition reflects Worf’s internal conflict over whether to accept, at long last, that he has lost his place in the Klingon world in favor of the Federation. While Worf’s choice is the Federation, we still see him making nonconforming decisions, like stabbing his brother or wiping his memory. This is not defanged, wimpy Worf from the latter seasons of TNG.

I don’t agree with Worf’s final decision respecting Kuhn. I don’t think you turn your back on family. I don’t think you gain by disavowing history and ignoring life’s lessons. It smacks of the memory erasure scene at the end of “Requiem for Methuselah,” one of the most controversial moments of the Original Series (and a sign the series had begun to lose its compass in Season Three). But this all makes for good television, and I concede that I am not a Klingon.

The erasure of Alexander in Worf’s line “I have no family” is so profound and tragic it must be a kind of mistake. Right?

The subplot with the space mines is also entertaining. It’s nice to see Kira in command of the Defiant! And what’s with all the flirting between Worf and Dax? This episode was action packed.

Kuhn is such a good character, I’m sorry it seems we won’t be seeing more of him.

4 out of 5 mek’leths.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Sons_of_Mogh_(episode)


by

Tags:

Comments

2 responses to “4.15 — “Sons of Mogh””

  1. Shayne Muelling Avatar

    another great DS9 performance by Tony Todd (who also played old Jake Sisko in The Visitor)! I yelled at the screen when Worf says “I have no family” – just terrible – but overall a great episode.

  2. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Wow, I totally forgot Jake existed until you mentioned it!

    I actually loved this episode and would say it’s my favorite Klingon episode pretty much ever. It is a rare Worf episode that respects him rather than sees him as a source of comic relief or a symbol to be beaten to prove that someone else is tough, or a petulant man-child.

    I’m OK with the memory-wipe in this case. It gives Kurn a path toward a decent life for himself that no other possible path could really offer. I think about Worf’s reaction to losing use of his legs, even with years of exposure to human culture, and I just don’t see Kurn making the psychological adjustment to Starfleet at this late date. I don’t think he would willingly turn his back on his family and I don’t think that Worf is actually doing that either. I’m sure he would respond if he found out that Kurn was in trouble in some way.

    So interesting about Tony Todd… I like him much better as Kurn than old Jake Sisko.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *