3.6 — “The Abandoned”

3.6 — “The Abandoned”

Plot: Quark buys a salvage ship from the Gamma Quadrant and discovers a baby inside. It grows rapidly, proving to be Jem’Hadar.

What I like: I like that “The Abandoned” is a chapter in an ongoing story, not complete by itself, building on what came before, and building up to something yet to come later. As such, Odo’s last line to Kira, “Major, about the boy… You were right” may not be the last word on Federation/Jem’Hadar relations.

Odo’s new lease on life after visiting the planet of the Changelings, demonstrated by his new quarters, is a trend I welcome and want to see develop further.

What isn’t good: IMDB quotes Avery Brooks as saying “for me, it was very much a story about young brown men, and, to some extent, a story about a society that is responsible for the creation of a generation of young men who are feared, who are addicted, who are potential killers.” This sounds right to me.

A story which dashes the idealism of Odo in wanting to reach the boy doesn’t sound like the Star Trek I love. It concludes, “Odo . . . you are listening to your heart not your head. That boy was created in a laboratory. His body, his mind, his instincts, are all designed to do one thing. To kill.” This is a piece of a longer story. This Jem’Hadar is no Hugh the Borg, however. He didn’t even get a name. I don’t think we will see him again.

What makes it Star Trek? Despite it all, Sisko lets the Jem’Hadar leave peacefully. He doesn’t turn him into a lab specimen. Odo returns unharmed.

Rating: 3 of 5 housewarming gifts.

http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/The_Abandoned_(episode)


by

Tags:

Comments

One response to “3.6 — “The Abandoned””

  1. Randi Cohen Avatar

    Well… I don’t love the technique of hologram fighting to “burn off” angry energy. Expressing anger in a physical way just strengthens it. I notice this when yelling vs not yelling when annoyed at my kids!

    And you can see it demonstrated in this episode also. There probably is no way to rehabilitate this guy because he does not want to be… but encouraging him to sublimate by, perhaps, engaging in some form of extreme sports or calisthenics would have been a better option. Also not sure it is a great strategy to tell the Jem Hadar not to revere you before he has some strategy and buy in about decreasing the aggression.

    My favorite parts are his cute developing relationship with Kira and Sisko getting schooled by a Dabo girl about prejudice, which can take many forms (Nice echoing of the major plot… and including it softens the message that sometimes people are incapable of transcending their circumstances).

    I also love that the Kira I know is back… much more in character than the last episode.

    Yes the outcome is depressing, for sure. But the original trek had plenty of irredeemable societies and characters… remember those half black half white people? To me what keeps this episode from being great is the lack of a connection to a clear moral point… other than that some can transcend their genes and some cannot? Still, i enjoyed it for the character moments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *